I'm divided on this one. I've met both of them and both are impressive people. However, both have made head scratching decisions whether in games (Porter) or in negotiations with players and teams (Luhnow). I don't think either deserves to be canned at this point, but guess I'd go Porter if forced to choose. I just don't see him being a manager that would make it with a contending team. Ideally, he'd go another year or two and then be replaced by a manager with a playoff acumen. Heck, give it another year or two and both may be on the way out.

I am a senior writer at thefantasyfix.com and a staff writer at bigleaguesmag.com. The Hall of Fame Index is also still for sale and as relevant as ever.