Your first one is a great question, allred. I'm not sure I'd trade Biggio for Morgan if it were more than a metaphysical hypothetical. Morgan's 2 best years with the Reds (1975 and 1976) are almost exactly comparable with Biggio's 1997 and 1998. And, while Morgan has 4 NL rings and 2 WS rings, his career postseason BA is a whopping .182, so nobody give me any grief about Morgan and Biggio in the postseason.

In short, a deal like that would be a dramatic step sideways - one HOF'er for a future HOF'er.